A Day in the Life of an Immigration Attorney

This piece was requested by a Tucson publication in early 2026. It wasn’t published, I believe, because said publication was fearful of printing the truth about immigration. I was too upset at the time to look for other publication venues. My research/interviews are still solid. I hope my blog readers will find it illuminating. Please let me know what you think.

Sixty-eight miles from the U.S.-Mexico border, in Tucson, Arizona, you might imagine  that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) picks up more migrants than anywhere else. Winter 2026 would prove you wrong.

What do American citizens know about the lives of undocumented immigrants in the United States? Having decided to tackle that worthwhile question, I set up interviews with three attorneys who engage daily with immigrants in Tucson.

There I was, back in Tucson during January and February 2026, where I had worked as a journalist for seventeen years. I moved to Minneapolis in 2021. The harsh Minnesota winter was not for me.

Soon after I arrived in Tucson on the first day of the new year, back in Minneapolis all hell rained down in Operation Metro Surge. I deemed it as a racist ploy by the Trump administration to clamp down on Somali immigrants, the majority of whom were American citizens.

ICE agents were wreaking havoc in frigid Minnesota, where less than 1 percent of the nation’s immigrants resided. Where more than 3,000 ICE thugs arrested and/or detained around 4,000 undocumented immigrants, legal immigrants, and U.S. citizens. Where they murdered two protesters, Renee Good and Alex Pretti.

In a wildly Democratic city, the home of Prince, Minnesota Nice, and the ubiquitous hot tater-tot dish, ICE agents were seizing humans off the streets who displayed Black or brown faces, or those who spoke with an accent. You know, foreigners.

My nine-year-old grandson, who lives in Minneapolis with his family, told me, “There’s an immigrant in my class from Mexico. He’s too afraid to come back to school now.” Before I left for Tucson, I had helped that positive and inquisitive immigrant boy with his reading.

Now what? I wondered. Did anyone know? What I discovered from the three Tucson attorneys I interviewed was that they had little idea what to expect from the federal government’s changing immigration stance.

“Do you think what’s going on in Minneapolis will happen here in Tucson?” Southwestern friends asked me. Of course, I had no way of knowing.

I invite you to come along with me to experience the guts of U.S. border patrol policy in the Southwest during winter 2026.

***

“This is Prisonville,” says Tucson attorney Cheryl Blum as we turn onto Jason Lopez Circle in Florence, Arizona, at the privately owned Central Arizona Florence State Correctional Complex, a federal prison. I accompanied Blum to meet with four new detained undocumented immigrant clients. (January 18, 2026)

Near the federal prison stands an Arizona State Prison, a Department of Homeland Security detention center. Down the road is the Florence Immigration and Refugee Rights Project headquarters, a nonprofit that has helped advise undocumented immigrants about their rights since 2003.

Inside the prison, a guard leads us into the visitation room with its round metal tables and attached stools, surrounded by stark white cinder-block walls.

“This is palliative legal care,” says Blum, who shows me a graph that will determine each man’s possible sentence for crossing the border illegally. The four men were arrested by U.S. Border Patrol in December 2025. Blum will strive for the lowest sentence for each of her new clients. Before each man steps out of a holding room, with a glass window where we can view them, Blum purchases a Coke and a bag of Fritos from the vending machines. A low-cost treat for each detainee while they discuss his future. Three of the men were apprehended by U.S. Border Patrol for crossing from Mexico into the U.S. illegally. One man was arrested in his Chicago home — where he had lived under the radar for ten years — until he acquired a D.U.I. and was arrested by ICE agents following his court appearance.

“What happens to detainees in Florence is complicated,” Blum explains: “They start out at the federal prison, where we are now. If it fills up they’re relocated to other facilities where they complete their sentences. As illegal immigrants, they aren’t simply let out the door after time served. ICE either deports them immediately or holds them to await asylum claims.”

One of Blum’s clients tells her (in Spanish) he was transported from Florence to a Miami facility and was then returned to Florence. Nobody could tell him why, he says. “We slept on the floor. It was very cold. People were dying around us.”

If caught, the consequence for a person’s first illegal entry onto U.S. soil used to result in their being deported, or a “catch and release” policy. No more. The current policy for an illegal immigrant, rather than deportation, is a misdemeanor charge, which can carry a prison term of up to six months. The second time an individual enters the U.S. illegally — per Title 8 section 1326 of the U.S. Code – it’s a felony charge, which may incur a maximum two-year sentence, and on subsequent reentries are punishable with a maximum of ten or twenty years.

Although these penalties are meant to deter illegal border crossings from Mexico, a felony designation has zero effect on many illegal crossings, says Blum. Individuals desperately in need of income for their family’s survival back home – the poorest of the poor – often risk repeated border crossings. This risk tolerance is an indication of how dire the economic prospects are for uneducated Mexicans living in their country. According to Blum, education is hard to come by. Even a janitor requires a high school diploma, and few working-class Mexicans achieve more than a sixth-grade education.

One of Blum’s four clients, a man who grinds rocks for five grains of gold (his weekly income to support his family), says he journeyed two hours from his Mexican mountain home for his job. He made more weekly than he would laboring in nearby fields. He crossed the U.S. -Mexico border in December 2025 to earn money for better tools; he intended to rejoin his family in Mexico.

“We’re dependent on cheap labor. Many Americans don’t want to pick fruit, replace roofs in 100-degree heat, or wipe people’s butts in nursing homes,” says Blum, who earlier in her career litigated federal cases such as national park saguaro vandalism. Since 2007, however, Blum’s contracted federal workload has slowly morphed into mostly illegal immigration cases.

With the steady rise in illegal border crossings, “there’s a level of enforcement and aggressive tactics I haven’t seen in my 15 years” as an immigration attorney, said Laura St. John, the legal director at the Florence Immigration and Refugee Rights Project.

Until recently, the Project has been funded by the federal government, with bipartisan approval. The nonprofit’s purpose has been to ensure that “all immigrants facing removal have access to counsel, understand their rights under the law, are treated fairly and humanely.” (https://firrp.org)

Although the Project’s funding has been terminated by the federal government, staff attorneys continue to provide free legal and social services to immigrant adults and children who face detention and potential deportation.

“The client who has always stayed with me,” said St. John in a December 2025 phone interview, was the man whom she met, sobbing in his cell. She asked him in Spanish, why he was crying.

“I’m so happy someone has finally come to see me,” he replied.

“People are so lost,” said St. John, who visited the crying man to explain immigrant rights and legal options prior to the court date that would decide his plight. Otherwise, legal behavior toward detainees occurs in secrecy.

“What shakes me to the core is no longer being sure I can trust my own government,” said St. John, as she described the Guatemalan government’s supposed request for the U.S. to send back detained Guatemalan children over Labor Day weekend 2025. It turned out that the Guatemalan government had made no such demand.

In the dark of night, between 10 p.m. and 3 a.m., unaccompanied refugee children were taken to planes at Tucson and Phoenix airports by ICE agents. The planes sat on the tarmac, waiting to take off for Guatemala, where children were previously abused, neglected, or trafficked. Therefore, Guatemalan children (designated as ages 10-23) risked their lives to leave their home country and travel north – on foot – to the United States.

Upon receiving a phone tip about this intended deportation, St. John and Florence Project staff sprang into action to obtain an emergency order from a judge, which released the children back into shelters to await proper hearings.

The federal government has greatly reduced illegal border crossings from Central America. Few dare cross now, as they hear about the current administration’s ICE crackdown on undocumented immigrants. As the trek from Central American countries is longer, and therefore more perilous to begin with, the word is out about risking long imprisonment in the United States for illegal crossings. But illegal crossings from Mexico continue.

One issue in the 2024 presidential campaign, a majority of Americans desired a reduction of undocumented immigrants flocking to the United States. This was the top issue that garnered votes for President Donald J. Trump in 2024 exit polls. Some reports have specified that from 2017 to 2020, many Americans were concerned that President Joseph R. Biden extended a “welcome” to the undocumented.

But, in the recent chaos and reported violence against both illegal and legal immigrants, and U.S. citizens, is this what Americans voted for? And in states such as Minnesota, undocumented immigrants – as well as U.S. citizens – have been detained within the United States, rather than at an international border.

Thousands of Twin Cities (Minneapolis and St. Paul) residents have been supporting each other in myriad but crucial ways for months. An 84-year-old woman, with whom I spoke, has been driving to work a 20-year-old, non-English-speaking pregnant woman whose husband was arrested by ICE. The wife had no idea where her husband was. She hid for safety under a blanket on the back seat of the driver’s car.

“Stand with Minnesota” protests took place around the U.S. on January 30, 2026. The one in Tucson drew thousands on its sunny downtown streets. I spoke with young and old participants, some of whom identified themselves as family members of those arrested by ICE. One woman told me, “I’m a citizen but my husband of 25 years is not. He had a tracker on him when he was taken by ICE on his way to work, so we know he was taken to the Florence prison. My husband is not a criminal. He’s a hard-working father who pays taxes. Our children are here with me today.”

ICE hasn’t descended on Tucson as it did last year during Operation Metro Surge in Minneapolis, but “there’s a targeted level of cruelty to get people to give up, which is meant to serve as a deterrent to people coming across the border,” St. John told me in December 2025, adding, a lack of transparency and due process on the part of Border Patrol or ICE keeps Florence Project attorneys hypervigilant.

A Tucson immigration attorney in private practice, Maurice (Mo) Goldman, engages in online cases or appears in downtown Tucson federal immigration hearings, located in the Evo A. DeConcini United States Courthouse. (In-person interview January 12, 2026)

This author witnessed one such detention hearing in which a row of undocumented immigrant men shuffled into the courtroom in orange jumpsuits, their hands and feet shackled together. These men are not hardened criminals, I thought to myself. They’re human beings on a quest for survival, for themselves and their families. What a sad sight.

Goldman’s case load is established by private individuals who hire him to process a green card or visa that will allow a detainee to stay in the United States to ultimately pursue citizenship. Or that’s how it used to be.

“What a waste of time and resources!” Goldman bemoans, referring to the case of his Tucson client (similar to an earlier Tucson case I mentioned), “who works hard, pays taxes, and helps raise his family of five U.S.-born children. His client applied for a visa and has lived in Tucson for 20 years. Dismissed as “low priority” for prosecution in 2024, his case resurfaced in early 2026.

“There’s no rhyme or reason for the Department of Homeland Security to prosecute this case again,” says Goldman, adding, if this client is deported, he would not be allowed to re-enter the U.S. legally for ten years, causing tremendous hardship for his family.

Some people ask why immigrants don’t enter the country according to legal paths instead of crossing the border illegally. “Every situation is different,” notes Goldman. “A neighbor got in my face recently. ‘I did it the right way when I immigrated, through marriage,’” she said.

But that was years ago, he explains. “If an undocumented immigrant is living with an American citizen, it counts as the individual’s first illegal border crossing.” Prior to April 1, 1997, proof that an illegal immigrant showed good moral character was grounds for suspending detention. In 1996, the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act was passed by Congress. This law created more significant barriers for obtaining a green card. Longer processing time and the dismantling of public assistance while detained, made it more difficult for undocumented immigrants to pursue a pathway to legal status. “The rules of engagement are changing all the time,” says Goldman, adding, there is less transparency because the Tucson ICE office no longer offers consistent policy information or holds meetings to discuss ongoing changes in immigration policy.

“The federal government should invest in a legal pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants, and they’re not,” says Goldman, lamenting, “They’re investing in enforcement. At this moment, the American Dream is gone.”

Blum points out that one in four Americans have immigrant ancestors. “We can’t absorb millions of potential immigrants,” she says. “Evading apprehension should not be rewarded when someone gets in without being caught.”

Immigration reform is long overdue. A viable solution, for Blum, is to allow staggered entries, whereby a certain number of undocumented immigrants are allowed to work in the United States for a limited time. Various proposals for improving U.S. immigration policy have been introduced, including one that candidate Trump railed against during the 2024 presidential campaign. The legislation would have given President Biden the authority to shut down the U.S.-Mexico border, making him look successful. Instead of trying a possible solution to the broken immigration system, Trump was more concerned with winning the election.

After months of bipartisan Senate negotiations unveiling “a $118 billion agreement to overhaul key Biden administration policies, the legislation hit a brick wall (NPR)”

On March 13, 2026, Arizona Senators Ruben Gallego and Mark Kelly “backed the Respect Local Communities Act to require the Department of Homeland Security to solicit public comments and receive written approval from state and local officials before constructing, acquiring, or operating any new ICE processing facility or detention center.”

Good luck with that! On Sept. 29, 2026, the Management & Training Corporation (MTC) and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agreed to operate MTC’s existing former private prison, near Silverbell and Sanders Roads in Marana as an ICE detention Center. No opening date has been set. The town of Marana is not a party to the agreement.

While Tucson attorneys decry the lack of straightforward communication between the federal government and local legal entities, it’s hard to know what the future may bring.

As Attorney Blum states, “I would like to see more people accept there’s nuance in immigration control,” recognizing that many people don’t acknowledge that it can’t merely be a matter of accepting unchecked immigration, or accepting no immigration. “Perhaps then,” she says, “We could come up with feasible solutions.”

Personal addendum: Since the Nov. 3 midterm elections resulted in a national Blue Tsunami, let’s advocate for a legal, compassionate, sensible immigration policy to take hold in Arizona and around these United States.

Sheila Wilensky is a freelance writer/editor living in Minneapolis. A former Tucson journalist and high school/college teacher, she strives to help readers understand history.

This entry was posted in America WTF?, Bopping Around Tucson, Family Matters, Fight wimpiness, For Love of History, Journalism/Writing, Out West, politics and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to A Day in the Life of an Immigration Attorney

  1. judykugel's avatar judykugel says:

    Yes, it was illuminating. Good for you! And keep up saying what needs to be heard.

  2. Kate's avatar Kate says:

    I am so sorry they wouldn’t publish this! Very well researched and of course, well written. Mo Goldman was a student at Green Fields Country Day School during my first years there. If you see him again, give him a hello from Kate the Librarian.

Leave a Reply